Shea
John Shea,
born 1817 (by age in census).
He mar
Ellen Eagar [born est c.1817].
She was apparently Catholic. Children were Catholic.
At son's bapt 1835 they are living
Listry, Kilbonane par, Co.Kerry (SE of Milltown).
They lived
Kilnabrack, Glanbehy par, Co.Kerry.
In Irish this is "Cill na mBreac",
which led to it being written as "Kilnamrack".
Living Kilnabrack as at
dau's bapt 1844.
Ellen died pre-1901.
John is
listed
in 1901 census
at his daughter's house in Kilnabrack Lower.
He is widower, farmer.
John and Ellen
had issue:
- John Shea,
bapt 26 Oct 1835, Milltown RC church, Co.Kerry.
See entry
from here.
- Margaret Shea,
bapt
22 November 1844 [Glenbeigh RC church].
See entry
from here.
The Ancestry
tree
by
Charles J. Gardner
claims that his family descends from Margaret Shea.
But the descent seems wrong:
-
The entry
for Margaret Shea says she
married Timothy Galvin.
-
However a search
for marriage of Margaret Shea
in Caherciveen union in 1860-1875 does not find her marrying anyone.
-
It does find a marriage in
1869
of a Margaret Shea and "Timothy Gallivan"
but this is not her (wrong father).
This couple then lived in Kenmare union.
See birth of twin daughters in 1878.
Gardner links to the marriage of one of these daughters in the US in
1910.
But, as explained, her mother is not our Margaret Shea.
-
Gardner's tree has many Ancestry "hints" which are wrong.
For example, it has Margaret marrying in 1865 in Killarney
but this is found here
and is not her (wrong father).
It links to a Margaret Galvin buried in Missouri in
1898
but this is also not her (too old).
Note that the entry
for Margaret
in the tree
by Frank Mullady
has her marrying Timothy O'Connor on 13 Jan 1874.
But that is found in Kenmare union
here
and is not her.
Conclusion: Nothing below Margaret's baptism is proved.
Margaret Shea is claimed to be ancestor of the following, but this seems false or at least unproved:
- Charlie Gardner, born 1920.
He had issue:
- Charles J. Gardner.
DNA match to (Blennerhassett Cashel family):
Desmond Conacher.
Other Gardner family members DNA match Desmond Conacher.
But the first job is to prove any of these people descend from Eagar.
- Catherine Shea,
Katie, Kate, born 1856.
Living Kilnabrack at mar.
She mar 16 Feb 1878
to John Riordan.
They are
listed
in 1901 census
at Kilnabrack Lower.
Her widowed father with them.
They had issue:
- Catherine Riordan, born 1895.
She mar John Sullivan and had issue:
- Catherine Geraldine Sullivan, born 1930.
She mar --- Mullady and had issue:
- C. Mullady.
DNA match to (Blennerhassett Cashel family):
Donal Duggan and
Mitrina Ryall and
Frank McGrath.
DNA match to (Cashel of Alaska):
David Price.
The RC baptism of John Shea,
26 Oct 1835.
The RC baptism of Margaret Shea,
22 November 1844.